I finally had the opportunity to eat at Osteria Papavero a couple weekends ago after talking about going there for months. It is a quaint, almost rustic feel Italian restaurant. When we arrived, it didn’t take long to get a table even though the restaurant is quite small. Our waitress was amazing and went through the menu with us and listed from memory all of the specials and the type of pasta available for the evening. I was impressed. We also spoke about the owners and how they are from Reggio Emilia, which is where I was last month. What a small world.
We started with some cocktails. We ordered the Little Italy and Pago Pago. Our waitress was spot on when she explained that dark notes of the Little Italy cocktail, which was perfect for the chilly night. We ordered the Mare for our antipasti. That night the Mare consisted of three appetizers: crab cake on top of tartar, peppercorn and coriander crusted tuna on bed of tomatoes, and white fish sausage on a puree. From my understanding, what is offered on the Mare may differ daily. My favorite of the trio was the tuna. It was seared flawlessly around the edges. I found the crab cake to be my least favorite because it was too salty for my taste, surprisingly, because I love salty food. In my opinion, the salt overpowered the crab flavor.
For my main entrée, I ordered the Risotto, which was made in a lobster broth with shrimp. My first bite of the Risotto was not great. The lobster broth was pungent and I almost didn’t like my dish. After thoroughly stirring the Risotto, the lobster flavor mellowed out and I was able to enjoy my dinner. Beware if you do not like the taste of seafood or fishiness. I also found the rice to be a bit harder than I would have liked. This was by far not my favorite Risotto but not the worst I’ve had.
My friend, Roy, ordered the pasta in place of the Tortelli that was not available that evening. It was crab and ricotta filled tortelli topped with seafood in a wine sauce. We both wanted to order that dish but I conceded. I had the waitress describe the entrée to us twice because that’s all I could think about so I couldn’t focus on what the other specials were. It was delicious. If you like a good mixture of seafood and filled pasta, I definitely recommend and especially with the Gnocco Fritto. It is puffed bread that has a layer of salt on top of it. I enjoyed it so much that I had to know the name of it.
At the end of the night, I ordered an espresso. I mean you can’t go to an authentic Italian restaurant and not get one. We ordered the Bundino di Caramello for dessert. The butterscotch pudding topped with the whippiest cream and cocoa powder was divine, which made it difficult to want to share. We ended the night with grappa like you would in Italy. We ordered the Pinot Noir grappa and it sure did help clear my nostrils and my digestive system. I enjoyed my experience at Osteria Papavero and will be returning.